Gold’s explosive rally may reflect a monetary regime shift, not a classic bubble


A Reuters opinion piece is bullish gold. It’s a long and detailed piece, I’ve summarised below:

Gold’s Surge: Bubble or Paradigm Shift?

  • Gold is up more than 60% this year — its strongest gain in nearly 50 years — raising the question of bubble vs. structural repricing.

  • Inflation-adjusted, gold is at its most expensive ever, yet speculative mania is absent.

What’s changed?

  • Historically, gold moved inversely with real yields.

  • Since 2022, gold has risen despite rising real yields and falling inflation — a major break from past behaviour.

Key catalyst

  • The U.S. seizure of Russia’s FX reserves shook confidence in dollar-denominated assets.

  • Central banks began buying gold as a sanction-proof, politically neutral reserve.

  • Official gold purchases have exceeded 1,000 tonnes annually for three consecutive years.

Why this doesn’t look like a bubble

  • ETF holdings are still 10% below 2020 highs.

  • Gold-miner ETF shares have shrunk by one-third.

  • Wall Street is sceptical, forecasting future gold prices well below spot.

  • Speculators are preoccupied with crypto and AI assets instead of metals.

Macro backdrop is radically different from the 1970s

  • The U.S. has shifted from creditor to largest global debtor.

  • U.S. federal debt has jumped from 30% to ~120% of GDP.

  • Fiscal deficits average ~6% of GDP.

  • Fed policy rates are falling, not rising into double digits.

What could drive the next phase

  • Private investors hold very little gold.

  • If they begin reallocating — even modestly — gold could see a second, much larger leg higher.

  • Bonds no longer hedge equities reliably; gold has become the only consistent risk-off asset in recent turbulence.